Japanese Revisionism: Latest episode

I notice a phenomenon here that is common on most discussion boards dealing with recent history, that is, attempting to defray or mitigate guilt for the deeds of countries like Japan and Nazi Germany by accusing Allied Nations and most particularly the US of equally reprehensible actions.

Certainly there are legitimate instances of heavy handed and in a very small number of cases criminal deeds that occurred in the course of a long and brutal war that was forced on the accused by the aggressive actions of the Axis nations. In this alone we have someone who accuses the U.S. and Britain of causing the war with Japan while steadfastly refusing to address Japan’s aggressive and criminal actions which led to the supposed provocative actions of said nations.

Another phenomenon that is common on WW 2 discussion boards is that it’s almost mandatory to denigrate the US and it’s contribution to the war effort. Surprisingly this attitude is limited to a few right wing kooks or neo-Nazis but is prevalent even among Europeans who benefited immeasurably from US our efforts to liberate Europe. It seems to be more common to see criticism of not only the US as a nation but even of the soldiers who were fighting and dieing their way across continental Europe in actions that saw the removal of an oppressive and murderous occupier. Why the resentment?

I understand that in today’s world many see the US as a bully because of it’s willingness to assert it’s economic and political and military power. That however is a completely different discussion. Perhaps it’s just too difficult to separate the two issues?

In Europe there is a tendency to react negatively to Hollywood’s and the media’s portrayal that the US won the war. Recent films portraying the US as capturing the Enigma machine and US pilots saving the day in the BoB as examples tend to give the impression that the US ignores any other contribution and indeed will re-write history to aggrandize itself. The general idea on some forums from Americans that the war started in 1941 (rather similar to WW1 when the US entered the war in 1917 and won it after the British and French had been sitting on their rears for years).

Couple this with the attitude that gets noticed on many forums I am on with a certain type of American who beats his chest and says all enemies of the US should be killed, if 100 civilians have to die or be tortured to save one US serviceman’s life its worth it. A recent one I have seen is an increase in the claim that (from alleged USMC persons, they always seem to be ex marines) that the US should make people fear the US so much that they will never consider attacking anything American.

Modern perception quickly colours the past, and the loud voice of a few tends to get noticed more than the silence of the majority.

I can see that. Especially if someone is silly enough to consider Hollywood a source of historical information.

On the other hand Capt. Rafe McCawley did single handedly win both the European and Pacific theaters of war. Anyone who disputes this is a know nothing fascist.

I think that Hollywood is the reason I became interested in History - I knew that so much I saw in the movies was wrong so I started to read and find out for myself.
I believe that movies (and TV) are still where most people get their history. How many will bother to read anything about the Tuskegee Airmen before, or after, they see the movie?