WWI: The Great War
There was a TERRIBLE PC games released in 2004 called, World War I and it was stunning in it’s inaccuracy. First off, I would have liked to have seen things like trenches and barbed wire. Instead I saw German tanks and towers with machine guns protecting open, unshelled fields…against cavalry. WTF?
I was seriously perplexed by this game. Why go through all the effort of programming without making in the slightest historical inquiry.
To say this game is crappy is an enormous understatement. The text in is full of typos and seems like the first languange of the programmers wasn’t english. Then the game plays like a RTS where you build barracks and stuff to create thousands of units that you have no hope of clicking and controlling. And there’s some lame excuse that, “contrary to popular belief, WWI wasn’t all about trenches and barbed wire” which is complete bull (except for the Eastern front…but that’s not what is depicted here. In fact, I’m not sure what is depicted. But it’s a sad, sad excuse for a game and isn’t fun - even when belief is suspended.
Wings of War
Another absolute stunner of a game. For PC and Xbox. Another games that paid zero attention to history. It’s a flight game…but I won’t say sim. Did you know that biplanes used missles? Enough said.
But the game itself is beautiful and plays well…in an very arcade like way. But I just couldn’t forgive it for being so far from WWI.
1914:Shells of Fury
A sub sum from WWI! At least they make an effort here to be historically accurate. The only real problem I have with this game is…it’s a sub sim. And pre-sonar so you’re basically blind in the water and it was never fun, IMHO, to be a submariner.
It has Q-ships and is pleasing enough. But I know in my heart, I wanting a good, no great, land game. I was so hopeful when I saw the title…that the shells were in a barrage, not from a solitary deck gun.
That said, this is still the best non-flight WWI game on the market.
Hogs of War
World War I fought by Pigs. Yes, pigs wearing uniforms. That’s as far as I got.
My Game
I am a boardgame designer and I have an awesome idea of how to make a WWI land game that actually works. I’ve got the rules all worked out for a boardgame and the computer game would simply be an expansion of this, using the same basic rule…which I am sure work. Now all I need is a couple millions dollars to put the game into action